IFOR Warns of Corporate Abuse of the Human Rights Council

Human Rights Council, 38th Session

27th/ 28th June 2018

Agenda Item 5 – General Debate

Speaker:    Derek BRETT

Contact:    derek.brett@ifor.org


I refer to the report of the Forum on Business and Human Rights.  


There can be no doubt that private business is oftern responsible for severe human rights violations.  It is urgent to ensure accountability for these.


Business can also abuse the processes of this Council.


Earlier this week,  we heard a British corporate lawyer, masquerading as an African ngo, delivering a statement which might have been drafted by the Eritrean Government denying the well-documented[1] charges against her client of exploiting slave labour in Eritrea, and making accusations against the other ngos which had taken the floor which if directed against States would have provoked points of order, or at the very least “rights of reply”.


Of course when a business obeys political instructions about with which partners and where it should work it is no longer a private actor but an arm of the State.  But States can and should tell businesses with whom they MAY NOT work because to do so would violate international law.  The most clear-cut case is the prohibition against supporting the economic activity of the illegal Israeli settlements in the occupied Arab territories, and we strongly uphold the work of the Office in compiling a blacklist of firms which breach this.




[1]     See Eritrea Focus, Mining and Repression in Eritrea: Corporate Complicity In Human Rights Abuses (Report to the All-Party Parliamentary Group on Eritrea), London, June 2018